A Look at Changes to the CBS Reality Show, Survivor

Mark Gordon BrownStarred Page By Mark Gordon Brown, 15th Jul 2011 | Follow this author | RSS Feed | Short URL http://nut.bz/2zhbic6n/
Posted in Wikinut>Reviews>Film & TV>Adventure

These are my observations in regards to the American version of the reality television show, Survivor. I have noticed some changes in Survivor and wish to share with the viewers my thoughts on these changes.

About Survivor

The reality show known as Survivor has been on CBS since May 2000, it came to America as the result of the success of the Swedish version created by Charlie Parsons. With producer, Mark Burnett, and host, Jeff Probst, Survivor has become amazingly popular. I have been watching ever season and have seen some changes in what they show on television and change to the show itself.

The first season was in Borneo, and was won by Richard Hatch, who surprised everyone by forming alliances and having a strategy right from the start. Richard Hatch is now a celebrity as a result of being on the show.

What Happened to Surviving?

In the early shows, Survivor focused more on “Surviving”, viewers saw how shelters were made, how people struggled to make fire (often with little success), and how they found food. It was not uncommon for long periods of the show to focus on watching one survivor or another try to catch fish, or gathering food.

The show no longer features much of this, I suppose you can only watch a person catch a fish so many times before it gets boring, after all, that is why we have fishing shows. Nonetheless I do miss some of this sort of thing. It was fun watching people put their primitive skills to the test, trying to build a shelter, or make a fire. Skills that many of us simply do not have, and wonder if we could do it if we had to.

Location Location Location

It seemed to me that in the first few seasons, most notably Survivor Season 3: Africa, more attention was given to the location, something I enjoyed seeing. Occasionally in the newer shows they show glimpses of animals in the area, and a few wide location shots, but nothing like they use to do.

One of the reasons I watch the show is to see the locations but it seems that often times the new Survivor shows are using locations they have already used.

More Physical Challenges

The challenges themselves have changed, becoming more physical, and less cultural. In the early shows the challenges on Survivor had a somewhat cultural angle to the location. I remember one challenge where Jeff read out some cultural information on the location and people had to go from hut to hut remembering what he told them and answering questions. In the Africa show they had to drink the blood of a cow, as per the culture of the area.

Food challenges use to be more common, you know the type - where the survivors would eat strange or unusual foods.

In more recent Survivor shows the challenges are mostly physical and do not have the cultural element. I miss this greatly.

The Focus is on Strategy

In the early shows we did see players working on strategy, conspiring with one and other, but this was balanced with other things (noted the location shots and showing people struggle with survival skills). In the more recent shows the producers, and editors, have primarily shown us personal conflicts and game play.

One thing I think that has become more popular in the shows is that they are showing more of the "social" game play, more strategy, backstabbing, lying, and trickery. In a way this makes me sad that so many viewers are hungry to watch this part of the game. It is like viewers are become gossip mongers, wanting to know who said what to whom and behind whose back. This makes me sad, in the same way I do not like gossip magazines.

I Have Spoken!

Thank heavens Jeff Probst still says “The tribe has spoken” when he snuffs out the torches, but did you notice they don't even call it Tribal Council any longer, and often simply refer to it as “Tribal”?

Don't get me wrong, I still love the show. It's one of my favorite reality shows, with The Amazing Race, being my favorite.

You might ask why I have not used pictures of Survivor? It is because most (if not all) images are owned by CBS and using them would be a copyright violation.

Become a Wikinut Writer


American, Cbs, Challenge, Council, Jeff Probst, Reality, Reward, Series, Show, Survivor, Tribal, Tribe, Tribes, Usa, Voted Out

Meet the author

author avatar Mark Gordon Brown
Raised in Michigan, I have a son who recently joined the Military. I am living in Canada with my wife where we have a hobby farm.

Share this page

moderator johnnydod moderated this page.
If you have any complaints about this content, please let us know


author avatar Delicia Powers
15th Jul 2011 (#)

An outstanding review, very informative! Thank you:0)

Reply to this comment

author avatar Denise O
15th Jul 2011 (#)

Mark, the captions on the photos cracked me up! I agree with you Mark, I miss how they use to dip into the cultures of the places they were playing the game. A great review on the show 'Survivor'. One of my favorites also. The captions are still cracking me up, I love the way you think young man. As always, outstanding work. Thank you for sharing.:)

Reply to this comment

author avatar Mark Gordon Brown
15th Jul 2011 (#)

Thanks Denice, I love the way you called me "young man", I am nearly 50!

Reply to this comment

author avatar tootsieharveystories
15th Jul 2011 (#)

Loved your view on "The Survivor."

Reply to this comment

author avatar Songbird B
16th Jul 2011 (#)

Great Star page, Mark, and 50 is still young! lol..I have not seen this show here in the UK, but what a great review this is..I too loved the titles under the wonderful images! Maybe you could do a page on what image sites and attribution would be recommended by Wikinut, as I am sure that this confuses so many people on here..

Reply to this comment

author avatar Carol Kinsman
17th Jul 2011 (#)

Nice page, Mark. I've never watched this show, but we rafted the Grand Canyon with a guy who's greatest dream was to be part of Survivor. I guess someday I'll have to watch just one.... :-)

Reply to this comment

author avatar J A Ridley
17th Jul 2011 (#)

We love this show, so much better than most scripted stuff. Your points are valid though, it used to be better for those exact reasons. Maybe this paper will influence the producers to return to the original format. Great star page funny photos. Why can't a review use photos of the reviewed?

Reply to this comment

author avatar Mark Gordon Brown
18th Jul 2011 (#)

JA Ridley, because the photos are still covered by copyright, and I dont feel like contacting CBS for permisson. Some reviews are bad, so the owner of the pictures might not be so willing to allow them.

Reply to this comment

author avatar Tranquilpen
25th Jan 2012 (#)

Thank you Mark for a splendid review of Survivor and the captions cracked me up as well. That's Denise alright, calling you young man at 50. I'm 60 and she calls me that as well. I love it! Thank you for being there for us in all respects.

Reply to this comment

author avatar Ptrikha
23rd May 2014 (#)

Great review of the show.

Reply to this comment

Add a comment
Can't login?